A Quiet Place was a beyond dreadful experience for him.
He received excellent reviews for John Brown's Body, very good reviews for Mr. Roberts, Devil's Disciple, good reviews for "The Dark is Light Enough" and I can't remember "Back to Methusalah."
It seems Methuselah was trashed as well. Although, I thought it was great after reading these largely bad reviews, that he came out, on a whole, largely unscathed.